Chicken Shepherd Pie

Chicken Sheppard Pie You have to wonder: if meatloaf is chic again, and fried
chicken is the rage, then can Shepherd pie be far behind on the 50’s Classic
Comfort Revival Plan?

My friend Deborah recently invited us over for Shepherd pie,
and it was the first time I’d thought about the dish, well since I contemplated
leaving my life of luxury and becoming the high Priestess of the First Feminist
Shepherd Temple.

And the last time I’d eaten Shepherd’s pie I was in a pub in
London, long before the advent of trendy Gastro Pubs, when it was just Pub food.
I stood looking at a cafeteria-style steamer tray of bangers and mash, and it
not only frightened me, but triggered my gag reflex. Being hungry and determined
to try authentic English Pub Food (and still trying to figure out why soggy
French fries are called chips) I spied a meaty stew with a topping of browned
mashed potatoes. I settled for the Shepherd Pie and hoped it would banish the
memory of a banger right out of my brain. This Shepherd pie was a meat stew
that was as much whiskey as it was meat and it was wonderful. Since then I’ve
tried to resurrect its popularity among the heathens, but it’s like fondue or
haggis, either you wind up preaching to the choir of the faithful, or you find yourself
all alone on the soapbox waving an empty fondue fork.

We couldn’t make it to Deb’s for her Shepherd Pie dinner,
but as I was faced with some left over chicken I thought it could be time to
update that classic. Donning my treasured and well worn Shepherd outfit, (no, I
don’t have a picture) I rounded up all the possible left over items in the
fridge (because shepherds are thrifty and never waste leftovers) and wondered
how on earth I could pull this together. Now, my dear Urban Husband, doesn’t
share my shepherd fantasies and frankly, I was worried I’d be serving Prison
Food instead of Shepherd’s Delight.


Step 1: Confit of Onion

Thinly sliced onions, very gently simmered in chicken stock,
with a star anise and a very hot chili pepper thrown in. The onions were sweet,
the anise added a hint of spice and the chili pepper a gentle whisper of heat.
To keep the party going, I added a good-sized glug of sherry and a small knob
of butter.

Step 2: The Potatoes

Peeled, and cubed, I put the spuds on to boil. Sheppard's Dream

Step 3: The Chicken

Cleaned the meat off the leftover roasted chicken and gave
it a coarse chop, then tossed the pieces in a mixing bowl.

Step 4: Left over rutabaga

I had some brown butter and sage sautéed rutabaga left
overs. I know, it's hard to believe there are leftovers from one of the all time great vegetable dishes. But it had been a pretty
big yellow turnip so the remnants went into the mixing bowl.

Step 5: Reduce

I took the onions out of the confit juice and added them to
the chicken mix, removed the star anise and habanera chili and let the juices
reduce into a thick sauce.

Step 6: Parmigianino Mashed Potatoes

Oh yeah. Grated a ton of ptarmigan cheese into those spuds
and whipped them up.

Step 7: Assemble

Gently stirring my mixing bowl of chicken, onions and turnip,
I placed them in chic little, un-Shepherd like baking dishes. Topped the stew
with the parm mashed potatoes, grated some more cheese on top and put the
dishes in the oven to bring everything up to bubbling hot. A minute under the
broiler to make the potatoes crunchy and the Chicken Shepherd Pie was ready.


I set this bubbling rustico dish in front of Urban Husband
and I didn’t say too much, even after the quizzical look, which could have been
prompted by my Shepherd outfit or because I’d just served him his very own bowl
of mashed potatoes. First forkful, second forkful, and then “What is this? It’s
good.” Whew, not Prison Food….and yes, it was delicious and I may have made a
convert to Shepherds Pie after all.


(And no. A Shepherd outfit is not a Shepherd-ess outfit. Get
your mind out of the gutter.)


Posted in


  1. John Sconzo on January 27, 2010 at 3:38 pm

    I think you may be on to something, Judith. I have always liked a good shepherd’s pie and even some that objectively were not so good. The time may very well be right for a revival. Move over, fried chicken!

Leave a Comment

For security, use of Google's reCAPTCHA service is required which is subject to the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

If you agree to these terms, please click here.